Five Guys in New York vs the US typical price
New York ranks 1 of 9 in our Five Guys price index (1 = cheapest). The Cheeseburger here is $0.31 above the US typical $14.99, the Milkshake $0.89 below the US typical $8.39 and the Hot Dog $0.12 above the US typical $9.47. The saving comes from the shake and the Regular Fries; the burgers themselves are a little above the national level, so a burger-only order is no bargain here.
How New York (Manhattan) compares
Our everyday basket — Cheeseburger, Regular Fries, Milkshake, Coca-Cola (bottle) — costs about $35.88 in New York (Manhattan). That is 1.5% below the US median of $36.44. The cheapest place in our sample came to $35.88 and the dearest to $38.72.
Basket price: New York (Manhattan) vs. the US
| Basket (delivery apps) | |
|---|---|
| New York (Manhattan) | $35.88 |
| US median | $36.44 |
| Cheapest city we checked | $35.88 |
| Dearest city we checked | $38.72 |
Compared with the US typical price, New York (Manhattan) is cheaper for Bacon Cheese Dog (-15%), Milkshake (-11%), Bacon Dog (-8%). It is dearer for Veggie Sandwich (+32%), Little Hamburger (+22%), Cheese Veggie Sandwich (+18%).
Full Five Guys menu prices in New York (Manhattan)
Burgers
| Item | Delivery apps | vs. US typical |
|---|---|---|
| Hamburger | $14.22 | +4% |
| Cheeseburger | $15.30 | +2% |
| Bacon Burger | $16.14 | +2% |
| Bacon Cheeseburger | $16.79 | −1% |
| Little Hamburger | $11.51 | +22% |
| Little Cheeseburger | $12.59 | +17% |
| Little Bacon Burger | $13.43 | +15% |
| Little Bacon Cheeseburger | $14.03 | +8% |
Hot dogs
| Item | Delivery apps | vs. US typical |
|---|---|---|
| Hot Dog | $9.59 | +1% |
| Cheese Dog | $10.19 | −4% |
| Bacon Dog | $10.67 | −8% |
| Bacon Cheese Dog | $11.03 | −15% |
Sandwiches
| Item | Delivery apps | vs. US typical |
|---|---|---|
| Patty Melt | $12.59 | +11% |
| Grilled Cheese | $9.11 | +15% |
| BLT | $10.79 | +11% |
| Veggie Sandwich | $8.87 | +32% |
| Cheese Veggie Sandwich | $9.47 | +18% |
Fries
| Item | Delivery apps | vs. US typical |
|---|---|---|
| Little Fries | $7.50 | +6% |
| Regular Fries | $8.70 | −3% |
| Large Fries | $10.02 | −7% |
| Little Cajun Fries | $7.50 | +6% |
| Regular Cajun Fries | $8.70 | −3% |
| Large Cajun Fries | $10.02 | −7% |
Milkshakes
| Item | Delivery apps | vs. US typical |
|---|---|---|
| Milkshake | $7.50 | −11% |
Drinks
| Item | Delivery apps | vs. US typical |
|---|---|---|
| Coca-Cola (bottle) | $4.38 | −4% |
| Coke Zero Sugar (bottle) | $4.38 | −4% |
| Diet Coke (bottle) | $4.38 | −5% |
| Sprite (bottle) | $4.38 | −4% |
| Simply Lemonade | $4.38 | −4% |
| Dasani water | $3.30 | same |
Median delivery-menu prices across 21 US locations (October 27, 2026), before delivery and service fees — usually a little more than at the counter. City prices: lowest of the New York (Manhattan) restaurants we checked.
Five Guys restaurants we checked in New York (Manhattan)
| Restaurant | Address | Basket | Breakfast (delivery menu) |
|---|---|---|---|
| 80 Maiden Ln. | 80 Maiden Ln., New York, NY 10038 | $35.88 | — |
| 296 Bleecker St. | 296 Bleecker St., New York, NY 10014 | $35.88 | — |
| 56 W. 14th St. | 56 West 14th Street, New York, NY 10011 | $35.88 | — |
Cities with similar prices
All 9 cities side by side: Five Guys prices by city.
Paid a different price? Tell us
Two taps, no account, no email. We check every report and update the prices ourselves.
Frequently asked questions
How much is a Five Guys Cheeseburger in New York?
$15.30 on the delivery menus we checked on October 27, 2026, against $14.99 for the typical US restaurant. Toppings are free.
How much are Five Guys fries in New York?
Little Fries $7.50, Regular $8.70 and Large $10.02. Cajun costs the same.
Is Five Guys expensive in New York?
New York is number 1 of 9 cities in our index; our order of a Cheeseburger, Regular Fries, a Milkshake and a Coke cost $35.88.
Why is Five Guys cheap in New York?
On delivery menus the Manhattan restaurants charged $7.50 for a Milkshake and $8.70 for Regular Fries, the lowest of the nine cities, which outweighs slightly dearer burgers.
Are these the prices in the restaurant?
They are Uber Eats menu prices before tax and fees. Counter and pickup prices are usually lower.