Chipotle prices in New York are among the highest in the country. We read the pickup menus of two Manhattan restaurants — 200 Varick St Frnt B and 4009 Broadway — on October 27, 2026: a Chicken Bowl cost $11.95 against $9.80 at the typical US restaurant, and guacamole $3.20 instead of $2.95.
New York ranked number 17 of 18 (1 = cheapest) in our Chipotle index, second only to San Francisco. Unlike most cities, even the extras cost more here: guacamole and chips are above the national median as well as the entrées. The two Manhattan restaurants — downtown near Hudson Square and uptown in Washington Heights — were within 15 cents of each other, so Manhattan pricing looks consistent across the borough.
Chipotle in New York vs the US
Lowest pickup price at the New York restaurants we checked on chipotle.com (October 27, 2026) vs the median of 24 US restaurants, before tax.
Our everyday basket — Chicken Burrito, Steak Bowl, Chicken Tacos (3), Chips & Guacamole, Fountain Soda / Iced Tea (22 fl oz) — costs about $46.70 in New York (Manhattan). That is 18.2% above the US median of $39.50. The cheapest place in our sample came to $35.55 and the dearest to $47.20.
Basket price: New York (Manhattan) vs. the US
In-restaurant prices from chipotle.com pickup menus (October 27, 2026, before tax).
Basket (in restaurant)
New York (Manhattan)
$46.70
US median
$39.50
Cheapest city we checked
$35.55
Dearest city we checked
$47.20
It is dearer for Chips & Fresh Tomato Salsa (+24%), High Protein Cup – Chicken (+24%), Extra Chicken (+24%).
Median in-restaurant prices from Chipotle's own chipotle.com pickup menus at 24 US restaurants (October 27, 2026), before tax. City prices: lowest of the New York (Manhattan) restaurants we checked.
Chipotle restaurants we checked in New York (Manhattan)
Basket = the same everyday items at each restaurant. Breakfast window as listed on chipotle.com on October 27, 2026.
Restaurant
Address
Basket
Breakfast hours
200 Varick St Frnt B
200 Varick St Frnt B, New York, NY, 10014-4810
$46.70
—
4009 Broadway
4009 Broadway, New York, NY, 10032-1508
$47.20
—
Even within New York (Manhattan) prices are not identical: the same basket cost $0.50 more at 4009 Broadway than at 200 Varick St Frnt B. Each restaurant is run by a franchisee who sets their own prices.
Two taps, no account, no email. We check every report and update the prices ourselves.
Frequently asked questions
How much is a Chipotle bowl in NYC?
$11.95 with chicken and $13.95 with steak at the cheaper of the two Manhattan restaurants we checked, before New York sales tax.
Is Chipotle more expensive in New York?
Yes. Our five-item order cost $46.70 in Manhattan against the US median shown above — only San Francisco was dearer.
How much is guac at Chipotle in NYC?
$3.20 to add to an entrée, $5.55 for chips and guacamole.
Are Chipotle prices the same across Manhattan?
Close: the two restaurants we checked, in Hudson Square and Washington Heights, differed by about 15 cents on entrées.
AR
AllRestaurantMenu Editorial Team
We record menu prices from live restaurant listings in each country we cover and pair them with official nutrition data, so you can compare before you order. Spotted a price that changed? Tell us — read how we check prices.
We use Google Analytics cookies to see which pages and tools help readers. Nothing is sold, no ads are personalised. Cookie policy