Olive Garden in New York means two very different price lists. We read the To Go menus of the Times Square restaurant and of the nearest suburban one, Secaucus in New Jersey, on October 27, 2026. Times Square is the most expensive Olive Garden we found anywhere: Chicken Alfredo costs $26.79 there against $21.79 in Secaucus and $21.79 at the typical US restaurant.
The gap is the story of Olive Garden prices in New York. The same dinner for two — Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Parmigiana, Calamari, Tiramisu and two soft drinks — came to $91.04 in Times Square and $74.54 in Secaucus, just across the Hudson. The Tour of Italy costs $29.99 in Times Square. The restaurant is also open later than any other we checked: until midnight Sunday to Thursday and 1 am on Friday and Saturday.
Olive Garden in New York vs the US
olivegarden.com To Go menus, October 27, 2026, before tax.
Our everyday basket — Chicken Alfredo, Chicken Parmigiana, Calamari, Tiramisu, Fountain soft drink, Fountain soft drink — costs about $74.54 in New York. That is right on the US median. The cheapest place in our sample came to $69.54 and the dearest to $79.04.
Basket price: New York vs. the US
In-restaurant prices from olivegarden.com To Go menus (October 27, 2026, before tax).
Basket (in restaurant)
New York
$74.54
US median
$74.54
Cheapest city we checked
$69.54
Dearest city we checked
$79.04
It is dearer for Domestic beer (Bud Light, Coors Light, Michelob Ultra…) (+19%), Fresh Brewed Sweet Iced Tea (+3%).
Median in-restaurant prices from Olive Garden's own olivegarden.com To Go menus at 24 US restaurants (October 27, 2026), before tax. City prices: lowest of the New York restaurants we checked.
Olive Garden restaurants we checked in New York
Basket = the same everyday items at each restaurant. Breakfast window as listed on olivegarden.com To Go on October 27, 2026.
Restaurant
Address
Basket
Breakfast hours
Secaucus - Millcreek Mall
500 Route 3 West, Secaucus, NJ
$74.54
—
NYC - Times Square
2 Times Square, New York, NY
$91.04
—
Even within New York prices are not identical: the same basket cost $16.50 more at NYC - Times Square than at Secaucus - Millcreek Mall. Each restaurant is run by a franchisee who sets their own prices.
Two taps, no account, no email. We check every report and update the prices ourselves.
Frequently asked questions
How much is Chicken Alfredo at Olive Garden in New York?
$21.79 in Secaucus and $26.79 at Times Square, against $21.79 at the typical US Olive Garden.
Is there an Olive Garden in Manhattan?
Yes, at 2 Times Square. It was the only Manhattan location our restaurant search on olivegarden.com returned; the next nearest was Secaucus, New Jersey.
How late is the Times Square Olive Garden open?
Until midnight Sunday to Thursday and until 1 am on Friday and Saturday, by its page on olivegarden.com.
Is lunch cheaper in New York too?
Yes. The lunch Chicken Parmigiana was $13.49 in Secaucus and $15.99 at Times Square, and the soup, salad and breadsticks lunch $9.99 at both.
How much is the Times Square Olive Garden?
Noticeably dearer than elsewhere: Chicken Alfredo $26.79, Tour of Italy $29.99, soup, salad and breadsticks $16.99 on its To Go menu.
AR
AllRestaurantMenu Editorial Team
We record menu prices from live restaurant listings in each country we cover and pair them with official nutrition data, so you can compare before you order. Spotted a price that changed? Tell us — read how we check prices.
We use Google Analytics cookies to see which pages and tools help readers. Nothing is sold, no ads are personalised. Cookie policy